- Introduction
Ensuring the boat is unsinkable is one of the most important safety considerations in building a small craft. The term "unsinkable" does not mean the boat cannot take water inside it, but that even in the event of complete flooding it has enough positive buoyancy to stay on the surface.
Achieving that depends on installing suitable flotation materials, which act as a permanent reserve of buoyancy. These materials must stay effective for the whole life of the boat, must not be affected by the marine environment, and must retain their properties even after long use.
Just as important as the quantity of material is its correct distribution within the hull. The point of the flotation is not only to avoid sinking, but to maintain the boat's stability after flooding. Correct geometric distribution between bow, stern and sides helps keep the boat as close to level as possible (level flotation) and reduces the risk of capsize.
A conservative design approach is used in this build. The natural buoyancy of the wooden structure is not taken into account in the calculations, so that the flotation system has an adequate safety margin regardless of what the boat itself contributes.
- Analysis and choice of flotation material
The purpose of installing flotation material is to ensure the boat has positive buoyancy in the event of complete flooding. The choice of material is based on its resistance to the marine environment, its chemical stability, zero water absorption, its mechanical properties, and how easily it can be worked and fitted.
The following categories of material were considered:
Extruded polystyrene (XPS)
Extruded polystyrene was rejected, as it has no resistance whatsoever to hydrocarbons. Even a small quantity of petrol or other fuel causes rapid chemical breakdown of the material, so that it dissolves and loses its mechanical and buoyancy properties.
Polyurethane foam (PU)
Two-part polyurethane foam (pour foam) was rejected, because over time it can absorb moisture, increasing its weight and reducing its effectiveness.
Closed-cell polyurethane foam sheet was also considered. Although it behaves better with regard to water absorption, it is very brittle and stiff, so it does not conform well to the curves of the frames and it crumbles when worked.
Polyethylene foam sheet (PE)
Closed-cell polyethylene foam sheet was chosen as the most suitable solution.
The main advantages of polyethylene (PE) foam are:
Practically zero water absorption.
Excellent resistance to fuels, oils and chemicals.
High resistance to ageing.
Great flexibility, allowing it to conform easily to the curves of the boat.
Low weight in itself, as its low density allows a lot of net buoyancy per unit volume.
Easily worked.
Although it costs around ten times as much as the other materials, its reliability, durability and long life fully justify the choice.
- Theoretical background and calculation of the flotation required
According to Archimedes' principle, any body immersed in a fluid experiences an upthrust equal to the weight of fluid it displaces. In fresh water, each litre of displaced volume provides about 1 kg of buoyancy, while in sea water the equivalent is about 1.025 kg.
The calculations in this study are carried out on the basis of fresh water, which is the worst-case scenario.
The total mass of the metal fittings and permanent equipment is estimated not to exceed 100 kg, distributed roughly as follows:
Outboard engine: 56 kg
Lithium battery: about 4 kg
Steering, controls and other fittings: up to 40 kg
Before the flotation material is finally installed, all the components will be accurately weighed.
On the conservative assumption above (ignoring the buoyancy the wooden structure provides), a minimum of about 100 L of net flotation volume is required simply to offset the weight of the equipment.
For real safety, a safety factor of at least 1.5 is applied, setting the required volume at 150 to 180 L (or more, if the available space allows).
That choice ensures a significant reserve buoyancy, improves the boat's behaviour in the event of flooding, and ensures that, under the design conditions assumed, the boat will stay on the surface until a rescue is completed.
- Fitting process and geometric distribution
Correct distribution of the flotation material is as important as the total quantity. The aim is not only to stop the boat sinking, but to keep it as stable and as level as possible in the event of complete flooding.
Phase A, filling the bow
The bow is a sealed and inaccessible space (dead space). Since the next stage of the build is closing that compartment permanently, the polyethylene sheet has to go in before it is decked over.
The available space was filled with as much sheet as possible, cut, fitted and wedged in, making sure it stayed put within the sealed volume. I put the sheets in layer by layer and glued them to each other. The result is a solid mass that cannot come out.
Before that, the stainless fitting for the mooring line was installed, because afterwards I will have no access.
Some photographs of the installation.
Phase B, reinforcing the stern
The stern carries most of the static load, mainly because of the outboard. For that reason about 50 to 60% of the total volume of flotation material will be placed either side of the motor well and under the aft benches.
That arrangement limits how far the stern settles in the event of flooding and helps keep the transom above the surface. This work will be done at a later stage of the build.
Phase C, distribution along the sides for stability
To improve transverse stability and reduce the chance of capsize, some of the polyethylene foam will be cut into strips and fitted as high as possible on the side walls of the boat.
That arrangement creates buoyancy at the sides, limits large angles of heel and helps keep the boat as level as possible (level flotation), even when the inside has filled with water.
The side flotation will be fitted once the main joinery work is complete.